According to an ever-growing number of popular doctors, researchers, and influencers and “gurus,” autophagy is the next big health breakthrough.
By making simple changes to your diet and lifestyle, they say, you can harness the power of this mysterious physiological phenomenon and . . .
In many cases, the arguments sound pretty convincing. Buzzwords, whiteboards, and diagrams abound.
In fact, if the strategies shared (usually fasting or low-carb dieting or a combination of both) only worked half as well as many “experts” claim, the long-term results could still be life-changing.
And so it’s no surprise that autophagy is one of the hottest “health hacks” around right now.
It really shouldn’t be, however, and you’ll learn why in this article. By the end, you’re going to understand . . .
Ready? Keep reading!
Table of Contents
Autophagy is a cellular process whereby various waste products that have built up within cells or in some cases entire cells are recycled into nutrients that can then be used for growth, repair, and fuel.
The word comes from the Greek prefix “auto,” meaning “self,” and “phagy,” meaning “to eat.” In other words, “self-eating.”
Although autophagy has recently become a catchword in the health and fitness space, scientists have known about this process for decades. In fact, the term was coined by the french scientist Christian de Duve, who also discovered the lysosome (more on this in a minute), earning him a Nobel prize in 1974.
To understand how autophagy works and why it matters, you need to first understand a bit about how cells function.
In order to produce energy, small structures inside your cells called mitochondria consume nutrients and convert them into adenosine triphosphate (ATP). This chemical is the basic fuel that powers the myriad processes that keep your body alive.
In this way, mitochondria are the “power plants” of your cells, and like any power plants, they produce waste that must be disposed of. And in this case, it mostly consists dead or damaged parts of cells and unused proteins.
The removal of this waste is important because if enough builds up in the cells, it can interfere with their ability to function properly.
To clean up these leftover byproducts, small structures called lysosomes patrol the insides of your cells, gobble up the trash, and break it down into amino acids and fatty acids. They also help prevent disease by attacking viruses and bacteria.
Think of lysosomes as cellular janitors and autophagy as how they go about their jobs.
Lysosomes do more than just “house cleaning” as well—if a cell is infected, cancerous, or damaged beyond repair, they can also destroy it and recycle its components.
So, that’s what autophagy is, now let’s learn a bit more about its effects in the body.
Use this workout and flexible dieting program to lose up to 10 pounds of fat and build muscle in just 30 days…without starving yourself or living in the gym.
Here’s one thing modern health gurus have right about autophagy: It’s not just healthy, it’s absolutely essential.
That’s why it’s always occurring in every cell in the body, and when it becomes compromised, you can develop many types of diseases and ailments.
For example, when scientists use drugs to turn off autophagy in mice, they can develop all kinds of health problems such as cancer, heart and liver dysfunction, retarded growth, anemia, and obesity.
Most of the studies on autophagy have been done on isolated cells (in-vitro) or animals, but at this point it’s generally accepted that autophagy plays an important role in warding off disease and dysfunction in humans as well.
That’s why many people claim that autophagy can . . .
Let’s take a closer look at each of these points.
The term “aging” refers to a progressive decline of physiological function.
More importantly, aging also comes with an increased risk of many diseases from cancer to heart disease to dementia.
Some people have taken this to mean that just about anything and everything associated with aging—from wrinkles to muscle weakness—can be cured if you can just increase autophagy.
That may or may not be true, but at this point we simply don’t know because the research isn’t available. The evidence confirms that autophagy affects aging in humans, but there’s currently no reliable way to control this process.
This whole “more/better autophagy = less/better aging” argument is reminiscent of the hype around telomeres from several years ago.
In case you missed it, scientists found that the lifespan of our cells is largely determined by finger-like structures on the end of our DNA called telomeres.
Every time a cell replicates, telomeres get a little bit shorter, and this gave rise to the theory that it might be possible to slow aging by limiting or reversing telomere shrinkage.
This kicked off a frenzy of research into telomeres starting in the mid-1970s. Nearly five decades later, we have a much better understanding of the function of telomeres, but we still don’t have a reliable way to measure their length, prevent them from shortening, or increase their length.
In other words, the science is currently about as useful as a picture of water to a person lost in a desert.
Autophagy is in the same boat.
Yes, it’s a natural biological process related to aging, and yes, we know that its decline is probably bad, but we don’t have a reliable way of using this knowledge to significantly impact aging.
The term “neurodegenerative disease” includes any disease that involves the loss of structure or function of the nervous system, and particularly the brain.
Some of the most common examples include Parkinson’s, Huntington’s, and Alzheimer’s diseases, and multiple sclerosis.
Scientists are still teasing out the primary factors that cause and contribute to these diseases, and one potential candidate involves the buildup of “misfolded” proteins.
Every structure in the body is largely made of protein—from microscopic mitochondria to major muscle groups—and the construction of them requires extreme attention to detail.
Most of the time, things work more or less perfectly, resulting in incredibly complex structures that work exactly as intended. Sometimes, though, the body’s “protein machinery” makes mistakes, producing “misfolded proteins” that can’t function properly.
If too many misfolded proteins accumulate in the body, they can interfere with cellular function and eventually cause disease. For example, scientists believe that a buildup of misfolded proteins may be one of the main contributors to Alzheimer’s disease.
It’s not entirely clear why this buildup occurs and it’s even less clear how to treat or prevent it, but it’s possible that insufficient or impaired autophagy could be a factor.
Autophagy does involve rounding up and recycling misfolded proteins, so it stands to reason that the decrease in autophagy associated with aging would result in more misfolded proteins in our bodies. And it’s even possible that at some point in our lives, the accumulation of misfolded proteins could outpace our body’s ability to destroy them.
In this way, autophagy could help protect against neurodegenerative disease by cleaning up these misfolded proteins before they have a chance to cause problems.
That said, until we know more about this relationship and, more importantly, how to actively and safely regulate it, we can’t do anything special (beyond “healthy living”) to increase our neurological resilience.
Cancer is a disease caused by uncontrolled division of abnormal cells in a part of the body.
If these defective, cancerous cells are allowed to multiply unchecked, they can develop into a mass called a tumor. Over time, this can interfere with many bodily functions and eventually cause death.
And guess what? All of us have had cancerous cells in our body, but in most cases, our bodies are able to identify and destroy them before the problems begin.
In many case, these cancerous cells are eliminated through the process of autophagy. This is why scientists think that autophagy can help protect against cancer in three ways:
As proof of this, some animal and in-vitro research shows that when the genes that increase autophagy are destroyed, tumor growth increases.
A recent review of the research on autophagy and cancer conducted by scientists at Soonchunhyang University Seoul Hospital came to more or less the same conclusion: One of the primary ways your body destroys cancerous cells before they can replicate and spread is through autophagy.
This is all well and good, but unfortunately, as with aging and neurodegenerative disease, there’s still no reliable way for us to manipulate autophagy to become more protective against cancer.
Again, we can focus on healthy living through proper diet, nutrition, exercise, sleep hygiene, stress management, and the like, but beyond that, there currently isn’t any reliable way to boost or enhance autophagy.
These days, if you read, listen to, or watch anything on autophagy, you’ll also end up learning about fasting, and intermittent fasting in particular.
The reason for this is simple: blood markers of autophagy increase when the body’s in a fasted state (scientists currently can’t directly measure autophagy, only observe chemical changes associated with it).
The nitty gritty details of how this works are beyond the scope of this article, but suffice to say that when insulin and amino acid levels rise, autophagy drops. Conversely, when insulin and amino acid levels drop, autophagy rises.
For example, in one study conducted by scientists at The University of Texas, just 3.5 grams of leucine (which minimally impacts insulin levels) was enough to significantly decrease blood markers of autophagy for three hours in young men and women.
Why do insulin and amino acids impact autophagy? Scientists aren’t sure yet, but a few potential explanations are as follows:
I mentioned above that there’s currently no way for to directly measure autophagy in humans. Instead, we have to look at various chemicals in the blood (blood markers) that we believe, based on other research, are associated with autophagy.
The methods used for measuring these blood markers are still relatively new and unreliable, which means we shouldn’t be quick to draw hard-and-fast conclusions from them. In time, it’s very possible that newer, more effective research tools will come along and invalidate much of what is currently believed.
This is a subtle but important point because many phony pundits like to blur the lines between these “best guesses” at what’s going on in the body and valid, observable, meaningful improvements in health and function.
The bottom line, however, is that while the relationship between fasting and autophagy is certainly an interesting topic, there are still far more unknowns than knowns.
That hasn’t stopped Internet gurus from promoting intermittent fasting as the single best way to increase autophagy, and thus a powerful strategy for improving health, immunity, and longevity.
Their logic looks like this:
A = Intermittent fasting increases autophagy
B = Autophagy is essential for slowing aging and avoiding disease
C = Intermittent fasting is essential for slowing aging and avoiding disease
This is a fine hypothesis to be tested with rigorous scientific study, but rigorous scientists the fake YouTube doctors (chiropractors and “naturopaths”) are not.
Instead, they’re often charlatans who present their information as gospel, even the “the ancient secret of health,” as Dr. Jason Fung, one of the main proponents of the fasting-for-autophagy fad, likes to say.
To “prove” the wonders of intermittent fasting, these dubious guys and gals often point to studies like this one, conducted by scientists at Keio University Graduate School of Pharmaceutical Sciences.
If you take such research at face value (i.e., simply read the abstracts), you might conclude that just one or two days of fasting here and there can breathe new life into virtually every organ in your body. In fact, this is what many people openly claim online.
When you dig into the details, though, you learn otherwise.
For instance, in the study cited above, the scientists took eight mice and gave half of them unlimited access to food and starved the others for two days. Then, all mice were euthanized and blood and tissue samples collected to measure markers of autophagy.
And sure enough, the mice that ate nothing showed significantly greater levels of blood markers of autophagy. Hooray for fasting!
There are a few rather obvious problems with this study:
That’s why this study, and others like it, are interesting fodder for discussion and further research, but most definitely not proof that intermittent fasting is an effective, scientifically proven way to live longer and healthier.
And especially when you consider that there’s scant human research on autophagy in general and very little understood about how it truly affects aging in humans.
In fact, it’s not clear that increasing autophagy above normal levels would be a good thing even if we could accomplish it. While autophagy does involve “cleaning” cells of waste products, it also often entails destroying cells, which isn’t necessarily something you want to accelerate.
In other words, while amphetamines would certainly help janitors do more work, maybe the outcome wouldn’t be a cleaner building.
An illustrative example of how little we really know about autophagy and general health comes from a study conducted by scientists at Ben-Gurion University of the Negev.
Researchers found higher levels of cellular autophagy in obese people than normal people, and that larger more insulin resistant fat cells had higher levels of autophagy than smaller and less insulin resistant ones.
In other words, autophagy was higher in less healthy people and cells than healthy ones, which flies directly into the teeth of claims that higher levels of autophagy are always good or always a good sign.
Scientists aren’t sure why this was the case, either. Maybe it’s because the body senses an excess of nutrients and is revving up autophagy to cope with the influx of proteins. Or, as the authors posited, maybe “ . . . it is also possible that increased autophagy signifies a process underlying increased cell death of hypertrophied adipocytes [swollen fat cells].”
That is, the scientists may have been witnessing the body using autophagy to kill off cells that were being pushed to their (literal) breaking point due to overeating. A sort of cellular triage, if you will.
This theory is supported by another study conducted by scientists at the University of Campinas, which also found that obesity led to runaway autophagy in the fat cells of both mice and humans.
So instead of thinking about increasing autophagy with “biohacks” or strategies like intermittent fasting, it’s better to think about not doing things that might decrease autophagy below healthy levels.
A good analogy for this is the cooling system in an engine.
Most engines have an optimal operating temperature. Things must be just right—not too hot or too cold—for the ideal function of all of the parts.
Likewise, humans require a certain amount of autophagy for optimal cellular function, and the body closely and automatically increases or decreases autophagy as needed.
Now, if the cooling system of an engine completely shut down, the engine would quickly overheat and stop working. And by the same token, cooling the engine as much as possible isn’t good, either.
Similarly, increasing autophagy as much as possible (however you might do that, if you can at all), isn’t necessarily better than generally living healthily and letting our body set the pace.
Ironically, given what we currently know, it’s entirely possible that eating well and staying active and fit are enough to get all of the benefits of autophagy, with no need for intermittent fasting.
For example, studies conducted by scientists at the University of Virginia, University of Texas, and University of Padova have shown that exercise can increase the expression of genes that are responsible for autophagy (an indicator that autophagy is functioning properly).
Studies conducted by scientists at the Biopotentials Sleep Center and University of Michigan Medical Center have also found that autophagy is linked to sleep cycles, so it’s possible that maintaining good sleep hygiene could go a long way in supporting autophagy.
It’s hard to sell pills, powders, and PDFs when that’s your position, though. And especially when you’re up against quacks who promise metabolic transformation at the flick of a dietary or lifestyle switch.
So, to summarize:
It’s not clear that intermittent fasting is an effective way to increase autophagy or that taking special measures to increase autophagy is even desirable.
Autophagy is a cellular process whereby various waste products or entire cells are recycled into nutrients that can then be used for growth, repair, and fuel.
It’s essential for proper bodily function, and when impaired, can contribute to the development of types of various disease and dysfunction.
In humans, it’s often claimed that enhancing autophagy can:
It’s very likely that autophagy plays a key role in all of these processes, but it’s not clear that it can be increased through special measures or that doing so would even be desirable for health and longevity.
Some studies show that fasting can increase blood markers of autophagy temporarily, which has sparked a veritable fasting frenzy among experts and laymen alike.
When you dive into the research, though, you quickly realize that it’s often wildly misrepresented and exaggerated as a ploy to sell supplements, books, courses, and the like. These self-styled gurus also conveniently overlook research that shows simple steps like staying active may support autophagy more than fancy diet protocols ever could.
So the bottom line is this:
Yes, autophagy is an important bodily function for living a long, healthy, vibrant life . . . just like breathing, converting glucose into ATP, digesting food, and many other natural functions that your body carries out every second of every day without you even realizing it.
That doesn’t mean, however, that it’s easy or even desirable to tamper with through dietary modifications, supplements, or other strange methods.
Instead, focus on eating well, staying active and fit, and sleeping well, and you’ll have the best chances of your body rewarding you with healthy, vitality, and longevity.